WTI Whipsaws From $99 to $106 After Trump Punts Hormuz Reopening

The Reversal

Heading into Trump's 9 PM ET address on April 1, crude was drifting lower. Pre-speech reports that Trump had hinted the conflict would end "fairly soon" pushed Brent down 1.15% to $100 and WTI down 1.41% to $98.71 by midday GMT. The market was positioned for de-escalation.

The speech delivered the opposite. Trump claimed the U.S. was "close to completing its goals" in Operation Epic Fury but stated that "the war is not over." He committed to hitting Iran over the next two to three weeks and — the detail that mattered most for supply — told allied nations that reopening the Strait of Hormuz was their responsibility, not America's. "They must cherish it, they must grab it," he said, while asserting the U.S. is "totally independent of the Middle East."

WTI jumped 5.9% to $106.02 within hours. Brent climbed 6.5% to $107.78. Heating oil led the energy complex at +7.85%, gasoline gained 6.17%, and Murban crude — the Gulf benchmark closest to the Hormuz disruption — spiked 10.65%. Oil broke above $101 while Trump was still speaking. S&P 500, Dow, and Nasdaq futures all dropped over 0.8%, while South Korea's Kospi fell more than 2%.

April's Supply Cliff

The speech landed on the same day the IEA issued its starkest warning yet. Executive Director Fatih Birol said April's oil supply loss would be double March's: "In April, there is nothing. The loss of oil in April will be twice the loss of oil in March." The agency estimates the Hormuz blockade has removed approximately 8 million barrels per day from global markets — the largest supply disruption since the 1970s.

The physical market is already cracking. South Korea disclosed it had secured only 50 million barrels of replacement crude for April against typical monthly imports of 80 million — a 37% shortfall. Korean petrochemical producers have begun issuing force majeure notices as feedstock dries up. A tanker leased to QatarEnergy was struck by an Iranian cruise missile in Qatari waters, underscoring that even rerouted shipping isn't safe. U.S. gasoline has passed $4 per gallon for the first time since 2022.

Trump's refusal to commit to reopening Hormuz changes the calculus. If the U.S. won't do it and no allied coalition materializes quickly, the blockade's supply destruction continues to compound daily.

The Bear Trap

The violence of the reversal has a positioning story underneath it. Traders poured a record $977 million into the ProShares UltraShort Bloomberg Crude Oil ETF (SCO) in March — a leveraged 2x inverse bet on crude falling. The thesis: diplomatic signals and war fatigue would pull prices back from their Hormuz-driven highs.

Instead, SCO dropped 41% in March, its worst month in nearly six years, as crude kept grinding higher. Analysts warned that "damaged infrastructure and logistics mean that oil prices are likely to remain elevated for long", making the short crude trade a dangerous one. The IEA now projects $80–85 per barrel as the new floor for Brent even after the conflict resolves — the pre-war price level has permanently shifted upward.

For anyone short crude heading into Trump's speech expecting dovish rhetoric, the 8% intraday swing was the worst possible outcome.

Trading on Hyperliquid

Trade CL on Hyperliquid with up to 20x leverage.