Robinhood's $1.5B Buyback Can't Stop the Bleeding as Analysts Keep Cutting

The Catalyst: Analyst Cuts Override Buyback Signal

Robinhood's board authorized a $1.5 billion share repurchase program on March 24 — the kind of move that's supposed to put a floor under a battered stock. It didn't work.

Within 48 hours, Goldman Sachs analyst James Yaro cut his price target from $102 to $91 while maintaining a buy rating, citing the broader crypto sector's 46% decline from its October 2025 peak. HOOD dropped 3% on that call alone. But Goldman wasn't the only one sharpening the knife: Bank of America slashed from $166 to $154, Cantor Fitzgerald from $130 to $100, and Truist from $130 to $120. Four firms cutting targets in rapid succession while a buyback is live sends a clear message — the Street thinks Robinhood's problems are bigger than capital return can fix.

The stock is now trading around $66, a 2026 low, and a far cry from the $117 average analyst target. That gap between target and price usually signals either a buying opportunity or that analysts haven't caught up to reality yet. Given the velocity of cuts, it looks like the latter is closing fast.

Crypto Revenue Is the Core Problem

The number that keeps showing up in every analyst note: crypto transaction revenue fell 38% year over year to $221 million in Q4 2025, while app crypto volumes cratered 52%. For a company that still derives a significant chunk of its transaction revenue from crypto, that's not a cyclical dip — it's a structural question.

Robinhood's overall business is actually performing well by most measures. Full-year 2025 revenues hit $4.5 billion, up 52% year over year. Options revenue grew 41% to $314 million per quarter. Net interest revenue climbed 39% to $411 million. Total platform assets reached $324 billion. But the market is pricing HOOD like a crypto company in a crypto downturn, and the 38% operating expense increase isn't helping the margin story.

The valuation problem is stark. HOOD trades at roughly 7.7x trailing price-to-tangible-book versus an industry average of 2.95x. That premium was defensible when crypto was booming and user growth was accelerating. With crypto volumes halved and the stock down 41% YTD, the premium is compressing toward the business Robinhood actually is rather than the one the market hoped it would become.

What the Buyback Tells You

A $1.5 billion buyback when your market cap has been cut roughly in half is management telling you they think the stock is cheap. It's also management telling you they don't have a better use for the capital — no acquisition, no product bet, no growth investment that would generate a higher return than buying back shares at $66.

That's a mixed signal for a company that's supposed to be in growth mode. Robinhood is simultaneously expanding into prediction markets (9 billion contracts traded in year one), completing the MIAXdx derivatives exchange acquisition with Susquehanna, rolling out banking features, and growing Gold subscriptions to 4.2 million. These are real businesses with real momentum. But the buyback suggests even management knows the growth story alone isn't enough to hold the stock here.

The 25-analyst consensus still reads "Moderate Buy" with a $117 average target, but the direction of revisions is uniformly down. Until crypto volumes stabilize or Robinhood proves its newer verticals can replace the lost crypto revenue, the path of least resistance for HOOD remains lower.

Trading on Hyperliquid

Trade HOOD on Hyperliquid with up to 20x leverage.